← All posts

November 9, 2026 · 3 min read

Married Without a Voice: Women's Legal Rights in the 1890s

By Sky Alexander

A Question Readers Ask Me

One of the questions I hear most about Forced to Love is some version of this: why didn't Hattie just say no? It's a fair question from where we sit today. But in the 1890s, a poor farmer's daughter in Gallatin, Missouri, had very few doors open to her. To understand Hattie's choice to marry Abner Garland to save her family, you have to understand the world that boxed her in.

So let's step back and look at what marriage meant, legally and practically, for a woman at the end of the nineteenth century.

When Husband and Wife Were One Person

American law inherited a principle from English common law called coverture. Under coverture, a married woman's legal identity was folded into her husband's. In the eyes of the law, husband and wife became one person, and that person was the husband.

In practice, that could mean a wife had limited ability to own property in her own name, sign contracts, keep her own wages, or bring a lawsuit without her husband. Over the second half of the 1800s, states began passing married women's property laws that chipped away at these rules, but the changes came unevenly, state by state and piece by piece. Even where the law was loosening, custom and economics often kept the old arrangement firmly in place.

In the eyes of the law, husband and wife became one person, and that person was the husband.

No Vote, Few Jobs, Little Choice

Women in Missouri could not vote in the 1890s. Nationwide, women would not win the vote until the Nineteenth Amendment in 1920. That meant women had no direct say in the very laws that governed their marriages and property.

Paid work was limited too, especially in rural areas. A farm girl might find work as a domestic servant, a seamstress, or perhaps a schoolteacher, but those jobs rarely paid enough to support a family. For a struggling household, a daughter's marriage to a man of means could look like the only way out of debt or ruin. Families sometimes saw marriage as an economic decision first and a romantic one second, if at all.

Leaving Was Rarely an Option

Divorce was legal, but it carried a heavy social stigma, especially for women. A divorced woman could face gossip, isolation, and serious money trouble, and the law did not always favor her when it came to property or her children. For many women, an unhappy marriage was simply something to be endured.

This is the world that makes Hattie's story so compelling to me. Her options weren't just narrow, they were almost nonexistent. The courage it took to carve out any independence at all, inside a system built to deny it, is what drew me to write about her in the first place.

Why This History Matters to the Saga

The Fires of Love & Hate is inspired by my great-grandmother Hattie, and the more I learned about the legal and social realities of her era, the more I admired the women of her generation. They lived under rules they had no hand in making, and many of them still found ways to protect their families, build lives, and claim their own dignity.

When you read about Hattie's journey from that forced marriage through wealth, betrayal, heartbreak, and hard-won independence, I hope you'll keep this backdrop in mind. Every bit of freedom she gains is something she had to take from a world that wasn't inclined to give it.

Meet Hattie for Yourself

If you want to see how one young woman faces these impossible choices, start with Forced to Love, Book One of The Fires of Love & Hate. You can read the first chapter free at https://thefiresofloveandhate.com/read-chapter-1, and Books One through Five are available now, with Book Six, Whirl Wind Romance, arriving November 1.